Privilege to Fail

Before I begin, please read this article:
What the Peace Corps Taught Me About Failure

This fellow volunteer has put into words that which many of us PCVs fail to express about our experience. And there’s that word again…fail. Failure. To be unsuccessful in achieving one’s goal. The action or state of not functioning. To break down, cease to work well.

According to these definitions, I have failed.

The reason for my month-long gap in blog posts was not due to lack of electricity or internet. Unable to process or admit what was happening to myself, I had few things to say that were positive. Without realizing it, I was slipping into a state of not functioning. I began to think I was unsuccessful in achieving my goal. I eventually ceased to work well and broke down.

You may think I sound like some malfunctioning piece of machinery. Just call the mechanic, tinker with my gadgetry, squirt some oil in those cracks and I will surely get moving again. Unfortunately the workings of my brain and intricacy of my emotions are slightly more complex than that of a Xerox. Of course if you have ever been on the receiving end of a glitchy copier, you may argue my point…

Anyway, as many of you know, Peace Corps has been a goal of mine for several years. A dream. It encapsulated my desire to serve others, be challenged, experience new cultures, live abroad, learn, grow. The perfect way to jump into the world of international development. Yet, I was blinded by my optimistic and idealistic nature. Like planning for a wedding and neglecting the reality of the marriage, I was slowly losing myself to the many challenges one faces when living in a foreign environment. Language barriers, isolation, unwanted attention, being treated like a child, not listened to, being homesick, lack of independence, not having a defined role at work, feeling guilty for not doing enough…the list feels endless. Yes, I was learning a lot about myself, but one day I simply did not recognize myself. Something had to change.

This may come as a surprise to some of you, as I have tended to keep my posts optimistic and even humorous at times. Because you have all supported me so much, I want to be honest with you. I have been in Washington, D.C. for a little over a week now receiving support and care from Peace Corps. First of all, I could write an entire entry on what it is like to go from the tiny dusty village roads to the shiny marble columns of DC in less than 48 hours. Talk about culture shock. It was like Back to the Future Part IV, only I couldn’t find Michael J. Fox.

I am still trying to process everything that has happened and even though the jetlag has worn off I still feel like I’m in a dream. Or that the last seven months were a dream. Anyway, the technical term for my situation is “medevac”, or being medically evacuated from country. This gives me the chance to regroup, explore my options, find solutions to my challenges, and ultimately decide what is best for me. Being back in the states, and in DC specifically, has given me a new perspective about being a young, white, American woman living in the rural hills of Rwanda.

With time to kill between appointments, I have taken the time to explore many of the museums and landmarks here in the area. One of the most profound exhibits I encountered was on the idea and history of race, especially in the U.S. I feel so ignorant. What I am going through as a PCV in Rwanda is what millions of people go through their entire lives here in the states. Maybe without the cultural or language differences in some cases, but still with all the other challenges that come along with being a minority. I have been privileged my whole life without thinking or understanding what life might be like for my Hispanic classmate or my black neighbor or my Korean coworker.

I would like to think that in theory I understood how life could be different for them. But how could it ever have resonated with me unless I experienced it myself? What times in my life have I been an outsider, a minority, or unaccepted? And here I am, a minority in Rwanda, yet I am still privileged because in this case, people want to be the minority that I represent. I have the option, no—the privilege, to remove myself from the situation and go home to a place where I am comfortable, where I understand the conversations surrounding me, where nobody stares at me, and where I can be whoever I want to be. In what other situation does a person of a minority have that option?

This safety net allows me the privilege to fail. The privilege to not just put my toes in the water, but jump head first into the deep end knowing that an oxygen tank awaits me at the bottom. Because if things get so bad that I am drowning, I can take a deep breath and be transported back home. I wish all of this wasn’t true. I wish that the concept of minorities based on skin color didn’t exist. I wish that people wouldn’t act differently or treat others differently because of it. Obviously I’m not the first to think this, but facing these realizations head-on has made me even more determined to go back to Rwanda and overcome those many challenges I listed earlier. There are many things in this world that I cannot change, cannot control. However, I can control my attitude and my actions towards those things.

In the words of William Ernest Henley:
I am the master of my fate. I am the captain of my soul.

About these ads

8 Responses to Privilege to Fail

  1. Suzanne Peterson

    Dear Liz,
    You’ve done an amazing job of expressing a very complex reality – with honesty and great depth and maturity. I know you get tired of hearing me say this but I’m so proud of you. My first real challenge of difference was many years ago when women were told we couldn’t be priests in the Episcopal Church. I know this is a shallow example compared to what you have experienced but . . . I remember thinking that I would never know what it was like to be black in the US, but I did remember what is was like to be different in a way I couldn’t change or hide. And I hoped and prayed I would never forget that feeling – first the shame and then the anger. You’re amazing in your depth of expression and I thinking ‘writing’ may also be in your future!! Love to you and your family and I hope you will have a wonderful Thanksgiving together. Please give my love to Jeff and Claudia too. Suzanne and Thembi.

  2. Dear Liz,
    you´ve probably not even been aware I was following your blog, yet here I am, having wanted to write you much earlier but considering your last entry I think its about time to finally give a notice… first of all, let me tell you that you´ve done a marvellous job and really put yourself out there, tried hard and what happened, to me (as well as to most others I´m sure) isn´t you failing but rather the privilege to learn, not to fail. You´ve done a great job so please keep this in mind!

    I am very sure it´s not so much the aim of Peace Corps as well as any other cultural exchange to necessarily change, transform or even so much noticeable improve conditions over there (although obviously that´d be outstanding- but not the norm) but to exchange cultural views, to enhance yours and other peoples´ lives and moreover, to connect the world. In this sense you already have succeeded, having lived there and now bringing back a so much broader understanding of how the world and its people on it work and live and experience life. …
    by the way, it´s me, Katie (Katrin), exchange student from Germany more than five years ago by now;) So… I think I can say some things about extreme situations and adaptation problems as well as “failure” in this context, having exchanged homes from Germany to the US when I was 16 as well as having lived and worked in the countryside of India for seven months, facing very much the same problems you´ve been describing. Additionally, studying development aid, its impact and problems a lot at uni have taught me some realities about the problems it entails by now.

    What I was about to say is: Living and being in the US was a tough lesson to me you know, and I have worked at childrens foster home in India, and according to your definition, failed as well. I kind of broke down by the end too, being geographically isolated and not being able to improve conditions over there it seemed. Luckily, I had made some good friends there with other volunteers so they could get me going. But you know, what I´ve learned (and it seems you too)is that its natural to need and crave for some structure, some people from at least roughly your cultural background or at least some people going through similar experiences as a you do-emmigrants, minorities all over the world do it, founding diasporas and such in order not to feel allone. Also- it´s not only you allone being responsible for the success of the whole project, it must be well implemended, being planned wisely and in cooperation with the people, and no professional in the world yet has a recipe for doing it succesfully for sure. So, everything comes or fails with the organisation behind it really… Development aid is a highly complex story and nothing that can be mastered alone, even the big multinational organisations fail all the time, so don´t put the burden of the world all on your shoulders! Also, maybe development aid might be an illusion scientists argue (in a nutshell) and the only solution maybe is international cooperation- exactly what you have done in small. Connecting the world and communicating, and bringing back what you have learned, telling people. You´ve been there and tried, that´s more than most can say of themselves. And you´ve learned a lot haven´t you, it definetly sounds like it…I´m very sure you can use this knowledge in whatever work-area or chapter in life you approach next. May it be the lesson of not being able to accomplish everything you want (although being so used to that growing up in the West and priviledged background!), or knowing more of how others do not have those privileges or how ethnically, racially and socially segregated society is and how people experience exclusion and difference. And how transcultural experience enriches life as well!

    Woo- this´s been a long post, didn´t expect me to write this much but your blog entry really inspired me (I hope my English is okay, I know very long German senctences;)) and surely others too. Thank you very much for sharing! You´ve done a great job Liz, and I really hope we´ll meet again at some point either in the US or Europe, give me notice whenever you´re abroad anywhere in Europe please!
    All the very best to you, get better soon, and say hi to your parents, they´ve been lovely back then. Best, Katie

  3. Victoria DeFrancisco

    Dear Liz,
    Yes, your message was surprising, but I’m so relieved to know you are taking care of yourself in the complexity of this situation. Funny how we think we’re going out to change the world, but the one who changes the most is oursleves — know you are not alone. I have been so impressed with your courage, self-reflexivity, and compassion throughout this journey, but never more than now. thank you for shareing it all! You take good care friend. Love, Victoria

  4. Hang in. There are lots of us who admire you just for the fact that the Peace Corp is something you wanted to do. Try to remember that we all are just doing the best we can. And in your case, I’d say the best you can is better than most.

  5. Christine Hooyman

    Liz –

    Rita and I were talking the other day and she mentioned that you tortured her by listing all the delicious food and hot showers you’d been enjoying in D.C. Not cool…

    But jokes aside, I hope you’re doing well and getting the support you need. Thanks for this blog post — I think it encapsulates a lot of what many of us are feeling or have felt at some point during service. Unpacking our privilege can be an overwhelmingly confusing and difficult process. It’s something I struggle with everyday here in Rwanda.

    We miss you and love you lots! If you need any recommendations on stuff to do with all your downtime, lemme know :)

  6. The responses to your blog are so heartfelt/soulfelt because you are able to articulate what is going on in your own Heart/Soul……
    unpacking our privilege
    we are going to change the world…Not. The world changes us….
    Kat…’what we might think as failures are really privileges to learn…’
    We are part of the Great Creation and we are all one.

  7. You failing is more graceful, productive and elegant than what most of us do when people think we succeed.

    Thinking of you, Cate

  8. Hi, Lizzie, You probably don’t go by Lizzie much these days but.. I am guessing you are facing the trauma others have faced since the Peace Corp started. You are a brave person for doing what you believed in. Sometimes our dreams are bigger than ourselves. I believe in you. I believe also there are people here in the US who could use your help. Is there still a US Peace corp that works here. You will be wonderful whatever you decide. Love you, Maggie Grace

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s